No woman came close to matching Mikaela Shiffrin on Monday. Not many men, either, for that matter.

The American skier dominated the combined race at the world championships to such a degree that she pondered how she stacked up against the opposite gender.

And for once – with men and women racing on the same course on the same day in the super-G part of the race – there was a direct comparison.

Shiffrin’s time in the super-G leg was third best among the women and would have placed her slightly more than two seconds behind men’s halfway leader James Crawford of Canada – but ahead of American teammate Jared Goldberg, who had a wild run down the Olympia delle Tofane course.

“There’s a big difference between men and women skiing. But when we can get sort of close to that and on days like today with this perfect, smooth conditions and just full attack, then it’s cool to find a comparison,” Shiffrin said. 

While the men and women raced on exactly the same super-G course, the slalom leg for the men was slightly more challenging – it contained more gates and thus more turns.

But the snow surface for both men and women in the slalom was the same – injected with water to the point where it resembled a sheet of sheer ice.

Shiffrin dug her sharp edges into the hard surface with apparent ease as she danced between the gates to post the fastest slalom leg in the women’s race – more than a half-second ahead of silver medalist Petra Vlhova.

In the final standings, Vlhova (0.86 seconds behind) and bronze medalist Michelle Gisin (0.89) were the only skiers within two seconds of Shiffrin’s combined time.

“Dominant” was the word that Tiger Shaw, the president and CEO of U.S. Ski and Snowboard, used to describe Shiffrin’s performance.

“Look at how fast she was in the super-G and then acing the slalom as usual,” Shaw said.

Super-G leader Federica Brignone lost her grip and fell at the third gate of the slalom. Two-time defending world champion Wendy Holdener also failed to finish the second leg.

Federica Brignone (ITA).

Likewise in the men’s race, 2017 world champion Luca Aerni was among those who failed to finish the slalom leg.

Austria’s Marco Schwarz narrowly edged Alexis Pinturault for gold while Loic Meillard took bronze despite finishing more than a second out.

So where might Shiffrin have finished in the men’s race? Well, it’s an inexact science, but Shiffrin required 45.05 seconds to clear the 57 turning gates of the women’s slalom course. Add in the three more turning gates on the men’s course, the equivalent of a 5.26% increase, and it translates to an extra 2.37 seconds.

That would have placed Shiffrin ninth overall in the men’s race.

“There’s a lot of talented girls skiing. I’m not surprised,” Kjetil Jansrud, the five-time Olympic medalist from Norway, said of the two-second gap between men and women after the super-G leg.

“Then again, two seconds on this course is quite a lot of time, because – well, it always is in skiing – but if there was anyone out there that thought the ladies would be like 10 seconds off, I could have already told them yesterday that that was wrong.”

Before injuries curtailed her career, Lindsey Vonn had campaigned for years for the right to race in downhill against men. She was one of the few female skiers to use longer men’s skis.

Vonn wanted to race against the men at the World Cup stop in Lake Louise, Alberta, where she won a record 18 times. The course in Cortina, where Vonn won 12 times, might have sufficed, too.

Bryce Bennett (USA).

As American downhiller Bryce Bennett noted, the Cortina course doesn’t have enough features on it to “separate” the men from the women, compared to more challenging tests in Kitzbühel, Austria, and Bormio.

“You can just arc as hard as you can,” Bennett said. “It’s a full sprint top to bottom. There’s nothing in your way of braking. It’s just ‘hammer.’ It is what it is.”

Shiffrin was charging so hard in the super-G that she nearly crashed into the finish banner.

“Everything just felt so nice,” Shiffrin said. “It was just maybe a couple spots where I felt like I was enjoying the turns too much and forgetting to get in my tuck. . I almost missed the finish.”

Having already collected a bronze in super-G last week, the victory gave Shiffrin an American-record nine career medals at worlds – one more than Vonn.

She also became the first skier — man or woman — to win gold medals at five straight worlds.

“When I was a little girl and I wanted to be the best in the world. I wrote in my diary, ‘I want to be the best skier in the world,'” Shiffrin said. “What does that mean? It’s a lot of hard work. It’s a lot of sacrifice and dedication.”

Shiffrin also set an American record with her sixth world championship title, breaking a tie with Ted Ligety, who retired last week. She has four golds in slalom and one in super-G from previous worlds and is among the main contenders in slalom and giant slalom later this week.

“Fifteen years later, 10 years after I started racing on the World Cup,” Shiffrin said, “It’s incredible to look back at everything.”

6 COMMENTS

  1. The distance was shorter in slalom, but over the same vertical drop. So the speed was certainly higher (or would have been higher for the men) on the straighter course. So this rough calculation is off.

    Lindsey might have placed top 30 for the men, but I doubt she would ever have skied Kitz. And maybe Mikaela on the right course, like when she won by 3.5 in Aspen would be top 10 for men…but she barely would have made Super-G flip today (30th) in a tiny field (AC never gets a lot of starters…).

    Let’s not pretend 🤷‍♂️. The women are fast and Mikaela’s an amazing skier, but the athleticism is completely different between genders.

  2. The set for the SG finish was near criminal. The fast line put racers dangerously close to the barrier for timing equipment. Big corrections were necessary for a few to miss the barrier. Very fortunate not to have had a bad crash w/ injuries there.

  3. Who cares???? Both the men and women are world class ski racers and each have their own talents. As a coach I actually watch more women’s video as their incredible skiing I think is more relatable to junior racers where the men are so aggressive it’s harder to analyze their technique. Mowing down gates may look cool, but the line the men are skiing is probably not realistic for many junior racers. I liked watching Marcel Hirscher because at 5’8″ and 165 lbs he had to ski more technical than some of the more powerful men.

  4. This was a bit difficult to follow. It is cool to see the women and men on the same Super-g course and not surprisingly the worlds best women are very fast. This comparison speaks for itself, same course, same conditions, just look at the times.

    Trying to compare the slalom times on two entirely different courses just doesn’t make any sense at all. And then to go and try to calculate the relative time difference based on number of turns…. on different courses? Why?

    I don’t know who wrote this but it doesn’t exactly demonstrate a thorough understanding of the sport.

  5. Let’s not forget that skiing is a sport of gravity and a heavier skier glides faster than a lighter one. Sure, that’s largely true for speed events (Super G, DH) but also GS and to a more subtle degree in Slalom. With men weighting about 50% more than women, this gives them a definite advantage.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here